American veterans of every branch standing together before the United States flag at dusk
Veterans Fighting For Veterans

We sit shoulder‑to‑shoulder with veterans and fight to win the benefits you earned.

Free ConsultationNo Fees Unless You Win
Stop Comparing Your Claim to Another Veteran's
VA-Accredited Agent #45147
← Back to the Blog

Advice from the Advocate

Stop Comparing Your Claim to Another Veteran's

August 10, 20261 min read

Your buddy got 70% for the "same" condition and you got 30%. That comparison is useless — and here is why.

It happens in every VFW hall and every online forum: "He got 70% for the same back condition and I only got 30%." I understand the frustration, but that comparison will lead you in the wrong direction every time.

Ratings are about evidence, not diagnosis

Two veterans with the "same" condition can have completely different files. Ratings under 38 CFR Part 4 are driven by measured severity — range of motion, frequency of flare-ups, functional loss — not by the name of the condition. His 70% reflects his evidence. Your 30% reflects yours.

Fix your file, not the comparison

Instead of asking why his number is higher, ask what his file has that yours does not: current measurements, a nexus opinion, documented flare-ups. Then build those into your own claim. The path to a higher rating runs through your evidence, not someone else's award letter.

Ready to Fight for the Rating You Earned?

We help veterans who were denied or under-rated. An accredited agent reviews every request personally — no fee unless you win.

Request Free Consultation